Penelope Trunk trots out one of her regularly visited themes: why grad school is a bad idea. It rankled me a bit but I do have to remember that she’s talking to twenty-somethings and I’m a forty-odder.
Her advice would be right-on to my 23-year-old self: I had very little direction, a graduate degree would have been wasted on me, and my next 25 years or so would be spent working (or not), gathering experience. and developing as a person.
The comments to her post are as opinionated, so she succeeded in stirring up some thoughts and opinions (much of it taking her to task–rightly–for her crack about the military.) Though I kind of understand her point — if you don’t have a direction, then entering grad school or the military could lead down paths that may not be right for you — it was a carelessly thought out remark.
As many of the commenters note, a graduate degree can bump up your pay grade (that’s what my employer does) and, after years of job-hopping, it can be useful to get a degree that tells the world — your bosses, your peers — that you do in fact know what you’re doing.
My manager is getting an MBA through NCSU and it’s been a transformative experience for him: he’s made great local contacts, he’s extended his skillset, and he now has a degree that qualifies him for bigger and better-paying jobs. Had he simply read the books and gone to local networking meet-ups, he would never have received the validation that he gets when he meets with his managers and with local executives in meetings set up by his school.
For myself, I have enjoyed my master’s experience tremendously. One of the most important things I learned was that I can apply my odd agglomeration of skills and abilities to more than the narrow band of activities I’ve grown accustomed to. The other important thing was that it awoke my intellectual side, which the last 25 years of work has rather successfully smothered (except when it was useful to the project, of course). And I’ve found my professors to be up to date on what’s happening in the big ol’ world outside of Manning and to be very generous with introductions to people they know in academe and industry, thus extending my personal network.
Still, her article is one of those goads that my reticular activating system has been sending my way as I contemplate the PhD. Does it make sense to leave a guaranteed paycheck to go to school full-time in this economy? Will I be able to find work as a 50-something PhD when I graduate? What, really, do I want to do with my life and will grad school help me get there?
That’s the real question I think Penelope means for her readers to ask themselves.
![Reblog this post [with Zemanta]](https://i0.wp.com/img.zemanta.com/reblog_e.png)
Brownstudy's Blog 
Or is grad school a way to become the person you always imagined you could be? Is it the right tool for your path? Another rephrasing of the question.
LikeLike
Ooh, Rani — as always, you ask provocative questions.
Reminds me of a recent column by your man David Brooks (http://www.nytimes.com/2009/01/27/opinion/27brooks.html), praising professiona dna institutions for encouraging skills, habits, and attitudes that, as he ends the piece, “often save us from our weaknesses and give meaning to life. ”
Yes, that thought has crossed my mind often today. The river needs banks against which it can push and flow; without the banks–those limits–there is no river.
LikeLike
Ah, David Brooks. That was a very short powerful piece. When I choose grad school I wasn’t sure I was ready for it — I sure wasn’t ready for New York or Teachers College. The experience wasn’t what I imagined it could be (my idealized version of the institution.) But I needed a catalyst to change my working identity. Now I can’t imagine being here, and happy, without it.
The river needs its banks. Some of the best designs emerge when you have severe constraints. My best poetry emerges when I write essays.
Anything is possible if you accept the possibility. Good luck!
p.s. David Brooks is PC’s man 🙂
LikeLike
I think the debate should largely center on what type of grad school you choose. Choosing a grad school that does not meet your needs can definitely leave you with a bad perception. I definitely did this and yes I went to grad school to delay the inevitable because I had no idea what I wanted to do when I graduated. What I did get in grad school was a sense of direction and I figured out what path I wanted. Now I have the job that I wanted. Although grad school did this for me, I absolutely hated my experience and I do not feel that what I learn will help me in my day to day job. All it did was help me get the job. The rest I learned on site. Once I got the job I quite grad school and am now looking for a masters program that will suite my needs rather than settling for a good name. What I found was a program that is online and for working professionals. Furthermore it centers its lessons around practical learning rather than theoretical learning. Everything i gained in grad school was all theory and most of it didn’t really unfold in the real world. Just my two cents.
LikeLike